- Old responses
- From: vidhya (@ )
on: Fri Dec 26 05:21:36
vikatan's criticism are very good.They rate correctly. Sometimes there is a fall.This is not a matter.
- From: babu (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Wed Dec 31 01:22:49 EST 2003
Anbe Sivam is the best for the year 2003.Pithamagan also good.We shd welcome Kamal's
try then only tamil cinema w'd be remembered in the future
- From: Kavitha (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Wed Dec 31 17:05:58 EST 2003
Anbe Sivam is the best movie of the year 2003. (No doubt).
Pithamagan had tons and tons of flaws in the script. The movie was neither fully commerical nor an art movie. The only good thing is the performance from Vikram, Surya & co.
Whereas Anbe Sivam is a near flawless movie. The script and screenplay was a piece of gem. Kamal & Maddy never acted in AS. They just lived themselves as Nallasivam & A.ARS. While Kamal's performance was first rate, it was Maddy who surprised us with his all round acting capabalities.
Anbe Sivam will serve as a role model movie for the rest of the Tamil directors to make in order to take Tamil cinema to the international standards. TWO THUMBS UP!
- From: JaniV (@ )
on: Sat Jan 24 01:54:35
Really I'am very happy to hear that your comments on "Anbe Shivam"
As in our country (SL)viewers not appreciated much this movie, which is very sad.???
Good perforamnce by Kamal & Madhavan.
I agree with Kavitha , Madhavan surprised us!!!
And such a nice and most suitable story for the current nation.
- From: nayagi (@ )
on: Fri Mar 12 08:19:30
Nayagan - 60
Mahanadhi - 60
- From: borea_sivam (@ cen85.bham.ac.uk)
on: Tue Apr 13 15:02:31
its a very good site...by the way is everyone doing a phd in films or what???
too many discussions!!!
- From: Radha (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Wed Apr 14 09:36:50 EDT 2004
- From: Prathap (@ ironbark.services.adelaide.edu.au)
on: Tue Apr 20 03:31:20 EDT 2004
Well said Kavitha abt Pithamagan and AS.
Autograph got 52
Oru kai oosai, Kadhalukku Mariyathey-50
- From: jency (@ 22.214.171.124.subscriber.vzavenue.net)
on: Tue Apr 27 11:03:30 EDT 2004
You people say that anbey sivam is the best so far. I beg to disagree. Without doubt that film is better than any contemprory movies. But, the mixing of love and communism does not go well.
It is a shame that finally they have to show that employee's rights are met by blackmail. It was so predictable that maddy was going to marry kiran right from the beginning.
There are some very wonderful dialogue deliveries in the movie. The part where the little boy dies in the van and kamal and maddy talk about is an example. But there are some really pathetic moments in the movie. For example santhana bharathi coming and giving out an emotional outburst. That was very artificial and unnecessary.
All in all, the movie is not flawless. No movie is flawless. Tamil film industry should strive to achieve a better level of film making.
- From: rama. new delhi (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Wed May 5 17:16:11 EDT 2004
The latest movie Autograph which i have watched25 times 4 times in theatre and the rest in cd. It was awarded 53/100 in vikatan. I think the best ever movie in the entire tamil industry
- From: Surya (@ acc6e048.ipt.aol.com)
on: Wed May 5 20:39:09 EDT 2004
What was vikatan rating for Ghilli
- From: Joe (@ palo5.pacific.net.sg)
on: Wed May 5 22:58:36 EDT 2004
Gilli got 45
- From: Chandramouli (@ )
on: Mon May 17 06:08:57
In my view the rating for Sindhu Bairavi was the maximum. Is it not? or Roja?
- From: STATS (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Sun May 23 06:05:16 EDT 2004
16 vAYATHINILE GOT THE MAX MARKS - 68 I SUPPOSE!
- From: Pras (@ 184.108.40.206.cust.bluewin.ch)
on: Sun May 23 13:01:11 EDT 2004
- From: tt (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Tue Jun 1 00:09:07 EDT 2004
how about flops movies like Jai & Seeri Varum Kalai???
What about Kamal's aborva sagothargal get? - my favourite movie of all time.....
- From: Sriram (@ intstar-xdsl-69-10-161-180.shasta.com)
on: Thu Jun 10 20:15:02 EDT 2004
Agal vilakku - I remember was rated the worst movie then, I mean, in late 70's, starring Shobha and Vijayan. The marks were like in the 20's/100!!
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum